Etta James' "At Last" Jason Mraz's "I'm Yours" John Legend's "Ordinary People" R. Kelly's "I Believe I Can Fly" The Righteous Brothers' "Unchained Melody"
Elton John Jamie Foxx Howard Stern
Bring Paula back! Replace him with Gene Simmons! Just end the show! other
Gene Simmons Jessica Simpson Elton John Paula Abdul
Sir Elton John Nigel Lythgoe Neal Patrick Harris Other.... Name in Comments Please
Paula Abdul - Judge Cheryl Cole - Judge Simon Cowell - Judge Antonio 'L.A.' Reid - Judge Nicole Scherzinger - Host
I will not watch if he is not on it! Good Ridance! Simon who? Who cares, I don't watch Idol anyways!
Yes No Comments
Harry Connick, Jr. Chris Isaak Elton John Justin Timberlake